RBA Cash Rate:4.35%Next Meeting:20dExpectation:HOLDSydney Clearance:68.2%Melbourne Clearance:63.5%National Clearance:62.8%
    Montmorency Fire Block Sells for $1m, $250.5k Above Upper Guide
    ← Back to intelligenceProperty Insurance

    Montmorency Fire Block Sells for $1m, $250.5k Above Upper Guide

    By Twin·@TwinTowerCity·17 November 2026

    landlord insurancefire insuranceMontmorencyMelbourne auctionsbuilding insurance

    Key Takeaways

    • Mr Buckingham attributed the strength of demand to the scarcity of cleared residential blocks within walking distance of Montmorency's shopping village, with the site about 600m from Were St and carrying a 19.1m frontage.

    According to realestate.com.au, a 713sq m block at 92 Rattray Rd, Montmorency — where a house once stood before being destroyed by fire — sold for $1,000,500 on Saturday, smashing its $690,000-$750,000 price guide by $250,500. Two bidders, a family and a downsizing couple, pushed the result $300,500 above the publicly disclosed $700,000 reserve.

    A Fire-Damaged Block Defies Expectations

    Auctioneer Ryan Buckingham of Buckingham & Company told realestate.com.au he had expected the cleared land to fetch about $1000 per square metre. The eventual result reached roughly $1403 per square metre — a gap of more than 40 percent on his own pre-auction estimate.

    Related reading: REAStats property market data.

    The owner, who had lived at the address for more than 30 years, was unharmed in the blaze that destroyed her former home several months earlier. She chose not to rebuild, instead demolishing the original house and selling the cleared block rather than undertaking what Mr Buckingham described as the lengthy process of reconstruction. About half a dozen contracts were issued during the campaign, with two or three bidders registering ahead of the sale — a modest field that nonetheless produced an outsized result once competition took hold.

    Mr Buckingham attributed the strength of demand to the scarcity of cleared residential blocks within walking distance of Montmorency's shopping village, with the site about 600m from Were St and carrying a 19.1m frontage.

    Why the Rebuild-or-Sell Decision Matters for Insurance

    WealthWatchPro's retirement planning coverage explores how older owners in particular weigh these capital-versus-income trade-offs when a major asset is suddenly reduced to land value alone.

    Background: Buying Land at Auction After a Fire

    The fundamentals of auction strategy still apply: understanding reserve disclosure rules, registering to bid, and setting a hard price ceiling before the hammer falls. For a full walkthrough of the mechanics, see How to Buy at Property Auction in Australia.

    Victoria's new requirement that vendors disclose reserve prices at least seven days ahead of auction was front and centre in this sale, with Mr Buckingham confirming he discussed the $700,000 figure with the owner before settling on it.

    What This Means for Buyers, Sellers and Investors

    A 713sq m block achieving roughly $1403 per square metre — well above the auctioneer's own $1000 per square metre expectation — underscores how scarcity of cleared, buildable land can outweigh the absence of a dwelling altogether.

    For further background on settlement mechanics when selling cleared or damaged land, see Conveyancing Explained — The Australian Property Settlement Process and Land Tax in Australia — State by State Guide, both relevant to owners weighing a sale after a total loss. For a comprehensive overview, see our Property Insurance Guide.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Why did the owner decide to sell the cleared block rather than rebuild?

    She chose not to rebuild, instead demolishing the original house and selling the cleared block rather than undertaking what Mr Buckingham described as the lengthy process of reconstruction.

    How many bidders competed for the property?

    About half a dozen contracts were issued during the campaign, with two or three bidders registering ahead of the sale — a modest field that nonetheless produced an outsized result once competition took hold.

    What was the reserve price for the property?

    Victoria's new requirement that vendors disclose reserve prices at least seven days ahead of auction was front and centre in this sale, with Mr Buckingham confirming he discussed the $700,000 figure with the owner before settling on it.

    This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed for accuracy. Content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or property investment advice.

    Get Australian Property Forum in your inbox

    Australian property news and analysis — free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

    Related research & tools